The history and legacy of Old Sandwich Golf Club
Historical roots and heritage
The roots of Old Sandwich Golf Club in Plymouth, Massachusetts, run deep. This special club is steeped in a history that's as rich as the game itself. Established in 2004, it’s relatively young compared to historic clubs like The Country Club in Brookline or Pine Valley. Yet, in a short span, it's carved a niche that celebrates timeless golf traditions and modern excellence.The club's name, Old Sandwich, harks back to its location on Old Sandwich Road, a historic path that dates to colonial times, enhancing the club's allure with a touch of antiquity. It is said that Henry David Thoreau himself roamed these parts, adding a layer of literary charm to the site.
The making of a modern classic
Despite being a newcomer in the world of elite golf clubs, its inception was driven by a vision to blend the natural beauty of the land with a challenging golf course. It's a place where the rugged landscape of New England meets the ingenuity of golf design. The collaboration of Bill Coore and Ben Crenshaw brought this vision to life, leveraging their renowned design philosophies that emphasize minimalism and harmony with the natural terrain.
Importantly, why it's different
What sets Old Sandwich apart is its dedication to the purity of golf. Unlike many modern clubs that blend residential areas and other amenities with the course, Old Sandwich is all about the game. This singular focus ensures that every aspect of the club, from the perfectly manicured fairways to the serene practice areas, is geared towards providing an unparalleled golfing experience.
A significant mark already made
Already, Old Sandwich has created waves in the golf community. Ranked among the top 100 courses in the U.S. by Golf Digest, it's recognized not just for its design but for the overall experience it offers. Andy Neher, a golf writer, noted, "Playing at Old Sandwich feels like stepping back in time while enjoying the best of modern golf."
This club prides itself in offering a secluded, intimate golfing session, where every hole tells a story, every bunker challenges skills, and every putt demands precision. With its undulating greens and strategically placed hazards, it’s a paradise for true golf enthusiasts.
The journey of Old Sandwich Golf Club is just beginning, but its foundation is as solid as the very earth it’s built upon. As you explore the other aspects of Old Sandwich, from its course design in part 2, to its exclusive amenities in part 3, you will find a club that respects tradition while embracing the future of golf.
If old-world charm and cutting-edge golf pique your interest, you might just find yourself captivated by the allure of Old Sandwich Golf Club.
For more on historic golf experiences, check out our detailed review of West Seattle Golf Course.
Course design by Coore & Crenshaw
Masterful design by coore & crenshaw
When it comes to course architecture, few names command as much respect as Ben Crenshaw and Bill Coore. Their partnership, known as Coore & Crenshaw, is the creative force behind Old Sandwich Golf Club located in Plymouth, Massachusetts. The duo is renowned for prioritizing natural terrain and classic design principles, and their work at Old Sandwich is a testament to this approach.
Old Sandwich is spread across a picturesque 450-acre site, showcasing the best of New England’s natural beauty. Crenshaw and Coore worked meticulously to ensure the course looks and feels like it's part of the landscape rather than an addition. Andy Neher, a well-known golf course critic, once said, “Playing at Old Sandwich feels like stepping into another time, unburdened by modern distractions.”
Each of the 18 holes has its own character and challenge, and the layout flows seamlessly from one hole to the next. With its rich variety of holes, golfers need to employ a diverse range of shots. For example, the signature hole, the 6th hole, combines a long par three (230 yards) with a green protected by bunkers on the left side. This hole requires not only precision but also thoughtful course management.
An interview with bill coore
In an interview about the Old Sandwich project, Bill Coore mentioned, “We wanted to create a course that honors the game’s traditions and challenges golfers of all skill levels while providing a uniquely New England golfing experience.” This mission is evident in the thoughtful design, which incorporates rolling fairways, strategic bunkering, and undulating greens.
Infusing the local essence
Old Sandwich's design also draws on the historical significance of the area. A unique feature is its incorporation of remnants from the Plymouth Colony era, including old rock walls and natural sand areas, which give the course a vintage and timeless ambiance. Henry David Thoreau’s writings about the Plymouth region’s landscape appear to come alive here.
Golfers who play at Old Sandwich are treated to more than just a round of golf; they experience a well-crafted blend of history, strategy, and natural beauty. This combination not only makes each round memorable but also reinforces the club’s status as one of America’s top golf courses.
If Old Sandwich caught your attention, don't miss our article on the American Dunes Golf Club: A Tribute to Heroes on the Greens.
Membership exclusivity and amenities
No ordinary membership
Old Sandwich Golf Club is a haven for a select few. Membership here isn’t just about paying dues; it’s about joining an exclusive community. Membership is strictly by invitation only. If you’re hoping to get in, you’ll need endorsements from existing members and a rigorous vetting process. It’s a place where privacy is cherished and camaraderie is celebrated.World-class amenities
Members of Old Sandwich Golf Club can enjoy state-of-the-art facilities. The plush clubhouse offers gourmet dining, a fitness center, and luxurious locker rooms. The practice facilities are top-notch, with a driving range and short game area that would make any pro jealous. Furthermore, personalized services ensure that each member’s experience is unique. From caddies to tailored golf lessons, everything is designed to enhance your game.An exquisite retreat
The club isn’t just about golf; it’s an escape. Nestled in the serene woodlands of Plymouth, Massachusetts, it's a place where you can unwind and savor the natural beauty. Some members even have private cabins on the property, offering a secluded retreat from the hustle and bustle. For more on such exclusive memberships, check out [which private islands offer the ultimate golfing paradise](https://www.myluxurygolf.com/blog/which-private-islands-offer-the-ultimate-golfing-paradise), where you can discover other luxurious golf experiences.Signature holes and playing experience
Unforgettable moments on Old Sandwich's signature holes
No matter how many times you play at Old Sandwich Golf Club, there’s always a moment of awe when you stand on the first tee. Designed by the legendary duo Bill Coore & Ben Crenshaw, every hole on the 6,908-yard course delivers a unique challenge and unmatched beauty.
Hole 3: A memorable par three
The third hole is one that often finds its way into discussions about this course. Playing at 184 yards, this par three requires precision. The green is well-protected by bunkers, making a straight shot essential. Missing left can leave a slick downhill chip to a green running away from you.
Hole 7: Strategy over power
Another standout is the seventh, a 426-yard par four. Your tee shot needs to land on the right side fairway to avoid the bunkers and provide a good angle into the green. Many find themselves laying up rather than risking a second shot into one of the most complex greens on the course.
Hole 13: The long par three
The 13th is a long par three stretching to 219 yards. Here, wind can play a crucial role. Well-placed bunkers on either side mean that only the most accurate club selection will safely land you on the putting surface. It's one of those holes where a par feels like a birdie.
Hole 18: The grand finale
Finally, the 18th hole, a 456-yard par four, offers a fittingly dramatic close to the round. An ideal drive will land you in the wide, forgiving middle fairway, but the second shot requires precision as the green is narrow with bunkers lurking on both flanks. A strong finish on the 18th always leaves golfers with a sense of accomplishment.
Comparisons to other world-class courses
While comparing golf courses is subjective, Old Sandwich shares a number of features with other elite clubs. Its strategic design and challenging yet fair layout often draw comparisons to Pine Valley and The Country Club in Brookline. However, Old Sandwich's Coore & Crenshaw craftsmanship gives it a distinct feel, with a focus on natural terrain and playability.
Even those familiar with Donald Ross courses will note Old Sandwich's clever use of the land, a hallmark of the classic American designs. It's not just the scenery but the thoughtful shot-making that makes rounds at Old Sandwich truly special.
The local impact of Old Sandwich Golf Club
Golf clubs of this caliber don't just influence the players; they leave an imprint on the surrounding community. Old Sandwich Golf Club in Plymouth, Massachusetts has bolstered local tourism, drawing visitors who contribute to the area's economy. The club also invests in youth golf initiatives and partners with local charities, creating a positive ripple effect beyond its luxurious fairways.
This sense of community extends to the club’s approach to environmental stewardship. The preservation of native land and thoughtful water usage set an example for sustainable golf course management in New England and beyond.
Comparisons with other prestigious golf clubs
Contrasting Old Sandwich with Pine Valley and The Country Club
When it comes to golf, comparisons are inevitable. Every golfer has a favorite course, but evaluating the charm and challenge of Old Sandwich Golf Club against other esteemed courses like Pine Valley or The Country Club offers rich insights.
Pine Valley, consistently ranked the top golf course in the U.S., is known for its extreme difficulty and unique design by George Crump and H.S. Colt. One of Pine Valley's standout features is its rugged terrain and dense bunkers. In contrast, Old Sandwich, designed by Coore & Crenshaw, offers a layout that's both challenging and forgiving, with wide fairways and strategic bunkers that demand precision.
The experience at Old Sandwich vs. The Country Club
The Country Club in Brookline, Massachusetts, holds a special place in golf history, having hosted numerous U.S. Open and Ryder Cup events. Its pedigree is undisputed, and its classic Donald Ross design presents a traditional golfing experience. On the other hand, Old Sandwich provides an alternative with its modern, yet timeless Coore & Crenshaw design, weaving the natural New England landscape into the course, making each round a unique adventure.
Both clubs offer amenities that enhance the golfing experience, but Old Sandwich’s exclusivity and intimate atmosphere give it an edge for those seeking privacy and personalized service. It's a place where every member feels like a VIP.
What sets Old Sandwich apart?
While Old Sandwich may not have the historic acclaim of Pine Valley or The Country Club, its design, exclusivity, and the sheer beauty of its natural surroundings make it a standout. The course’s layout, catering to both high-handicap and scratch golfers, provides a balanced challenge that’s invigorating rather than frustrating.
Bill Coore and Ben Crenshaw's philosophy of preserving the land’s natural contours makes for a course that feels organic and timeless. From wide-open fairways allowing for strategic tee shots to the undulating greens that test putting skills, Old Sandwich offers an engaging round every time.
The personal touch: Member experiences
Members often cite community and camaraderie as key factors in their experience at Old Sandwich. A story shared by Andy Neher, a longtime member, highlights this: “I’ve played courses around the world, but what makes Old Sandwich special is the fellowship. Whether it’s a casual round or a club event, you feel part of something unique.”
This sense of belonging is perhaps Old Sandwich’s greatest asset. In an era where some clubs can feel transactional, Old Sandwich maintains a warm, welcoming atmosphere that fosters lasting friendships.
In the end, when comparing Old Sandwich Golf Club with the likes of Pine Valley and The Country Club, it's clear that each has its own strengths. Yet, Old Sandwich’s combination of world-class design, beautiful landscapes, and a close-knit community gives it an edge that’s hard to beat.
